Original review plus 8 dated follow-up sections, with findings, accepted risks, fixes, deferred work and coverage limits in this file.
Review summary and follow-ups
Status: Mixed tool outcomes.
Result
Slither and Aderyn produced raw static signals; Echidna completed a bounded compatibility campaign; Halmos retained unresolved symbolic checks.
Scope and limits
Raw detector counts are not confirmed vulnerabilities. Echidna native states did not reach formal PASS. Halmos had five unresolved symbolic checks. See the internal audit register for source-specific disposition.
Original run evidence is preserved separately. The findings and project responses on this page record the subsequent owner review and remediation status. This summary does not certify deployment safety or count historical Veridise and V12 work as coverage of this freeze.
<!-- current-followups -->
Current project response
Project responses updated October 9, 2026. Latest inventory: 133 observations including duplicates; 125 accepted, two locally remediated Periphery observations, six deferred in whole or part, zero undecided contract portions. The Periphery fix passed 43 contract and 21 SDK tests; the owner waived its additional independent re-audit, which was not run. Acceptance is not remediation; deferred work stays open.
Astra · October 6 accounting review
Reviewed source: 91206a4ed18c514cdad3f8e8b09e0ca08ffd3ffb. Status captured 2026-10-06.
Recorded outcome: INCOMPLETEIDENTITYVERIFICATION.
Coverage: FIRSTPASSSEALED; complete seven-file FullRange primary scope; dependency extents in coverage.csv.
Runner model selection: gpt-6-astra. Historical returned-model field: not independently returned. Separate server-attested identity: not independently returned. Requested reasoning setting ultra. Returned effort: not independently echoed.
Harness revision: abc9fa370c5374c98da8192c7fdf7bc214886a710732bf0c15ad46422d107044. FullRange-focused scope and supporting integrations; this is not a new 39-contract review.
Later source changes include manager permissions, forced exit for revoked managers, buyback basket selection, richer events, launch caps, component getters, and fee-preparing Periphery redemption. October 8 follow-ups reviewed the resulting October 7 candidate. The later October 9 fee opt-out received local validation and owner acceptance with the additional re-audit waived.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Astra · October 6 authority review
Reviewed source: 91206a4ed18c514cdad3f8e8b09e0ca08ffd3ffb. Status captured 2026-10-06.
Recorded outcome: INCOMPLETEIDENTITYVERIFICATION.
Coverage: FIRSTPASSSEALED; complete seven-file FullRange primary scope; dependency extents in coverage.csv.
Runner model selection: gpt-6-astra. Historical returned-model field: not independently returned. Separate server-attested identity: not independently returned. Requested reasoning setting ultra. Returned effort: not independently echoed.
Harness revision: abc9fa370c5374c98da8192c7fdf7bc214886a710732bf0c15ad46422d107044. FullRange-focused scope and supporting integrations; this is not a new 39-contract review.
Later source changes include manager permissions, forced exit for revoked managers, buyback basket selection, richer events, launch caps, component getters, and fee-preparing Periphery redemption. October 8 follow-ups reviewed the resulting October 7 candidate. The later October 9 fee opt-out received local validation and owner acceptance with the additional re-audit waived.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Astra · October 8 accounting review
Reviewed source: ff973d5ca9e137f5561de88b22d8a53f221f9e19. Status captured 2026-10-09.
Coverage: 39OF39REVIEWEDCLAIM_VALIDATED.
Provenance: gpt-6-astra/ultra selected through Codex CLI; separate provider-returned identity unavailable.
Supporting client/indexer work is deferred. These reviews predate the October 9 fee opt-out.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Astra · October 8 authority review
Reviewed source: ff973d5ca9e137f5561de88b22d8a53f221f9e19. Status captured 2026-10-09.
Coverage: 39OF39REVIEWEDCLAIM_VALIDATED.
Provenance: gpt-6-astra/ultra selected through Codex CLI; separate provider-returned identity unavailable.
Supporting client/indexer work is deferred. These reviews predate the October 9 fee opt-out.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Reviewed source: ff973d5ca9e137f5561de88b22d8a53f221f9e19. Status captured 2026-10-09.
HALMOS
2026-10-08-completion-01 — EXECUTEDBOUNDEDWITHUNRESOLVEDSYMBOLIC_PROPERTIES. 16 targeted properties: 9 proved within bounds, 4 solver timeouts, 3 with no complete per-test result at wall cap; 0 confirmed counterexamples. Core/token representative Forge 29/29 pass. Outputs isolated from unsealed reviewers.
2026-10-08-continuation-02 — ONEBOUNDEDPROOFSIXORIGINALPROPERTIESINCONCLUSIVERESOURCESTOPPED. Unchanged original assertions with pinned Halmos/Yices and enlarged recorded bounds: one Mine property proved within bounds; two Fund solver timeouts; buyback wall stop; equal-seed stopped by 3 GB disk guard; rounding and Fund pro-rata not rerun. No counterexample; pre/post source, dependency, packet and tool checks passed.
2026-10-08-continuation-03 — ONEADDITIONALBOUNDEDPROOFFIVEORIGINALPROPERTIES_INCONCLUSIVE. All three disk-stopped/unrun original assertions retried in fresh isolated pinned Halmos/Yices context. Rounding proved within bounds (24 paths/8 completed, no model); equal-seed and Fund pro-rata reached unchanged 300/600s wall caps without complete results. No disk stop or counterexample; all pre/post candidate, dependency, packet, property and tool pins passed. Across original seven, two bounded proofs and five inconclusive.
2026-10-08-decomposition-04 — FIFTEENNARROWPROPERTIESSTATICPREPARATION_UNRUN. 15 audit-only narrow Halmos claims prepared with exact diff, tool pins and 77 commit-safe files. Static freeze/setup, source/dependency copies and both packets PASS; no Halmos/Forge/solver job run. Any later bounded proof remains separate from five original inconclusive properties.
2026-10-08-decomposition-04-math-muldiv — SOLVERTIMEOUTINCONCLUSIVE. checkequalSeedMulDiv: SOLVERTIMEOUTINCONCLUSIVE within recorded narrow audit-only scope. This does not upgrade the original assertion checkequalSeedAmountsHaveUnitPrice(uint96).
2026-10-08-decomposition-04-math-fixed — PROVEDWITHINRECORDED_BOUNDS. checkfixedSqrtAndTickBounds: PROVEDWITHINRECORDEDBOUNDS within recorded narrow audit-only scope. This does not upgrade the original assertion check_equalSeedAmountsHaveUnitPrice(uint96).
2026-10-08-decomposition-04-math-direct16 — WALLSTOPINCONCLUSIVE. checkequalSeedDirect16: WALLSTOPINCONCLUSIVE within recorded narrow audit-only scope. This does not upgrade the original assertion checkequalSeedAmountsHaveUnitPrice(uint96).
2026-10-08-decomposition-04-math-direct32 — NOCOMPLETEPERPROPERTYRESULT. checkequalSeedDirect32: NOCOMPLETEPERPROPERTYRESULT after the owner requested Daybreak-only handoff; the active Halmos child was stopped, post-integrity passed, and no later job was dispatched. This does not upgrade the original assertion checkequalSeedAmountsHaveUnitPrice(uint96).
2026-10-09-closeout-05 — ALLPREPAREDNARROWJOBSTERMINALFUZZREPLAYPASSEDORIGINALFIVEINCONCLUSIVE. All 11 previously unrun checks executed (4 bounded proofs, 5 solver timeouts, 2 wall stops); prior user-interrupted direct32 separately rerun at wall cap. All 15 narrow job names terminal: 5 bounded proofs, 6 solver timeouts, 4 wall stops; zero unrun. Exact assertion Forge replay 15/15 passed, 1024 fuzz runs per parameterized assertion. All pre/post integrity and 361 sealed artifact entries verified. Five original symbolic properties remain inconclusive; no deployment clearance.
SLITHER
2026-10-08-claude-01 — RAWCAMPAIGNCOMPLETE_TRIAGED. 422 raw detector rows; 108 touch primary files; post-seal primary-row triage complete; no scanner alert established as a reachable exploit; conditional questions remain.
ADERYN
2026-10-08-claude-01 — RAWCAMPAIGNCOMPLETE_TRIAGED. 27 raw detector rows, all on primary files; post-seal primary-row triage complete; no scanner alert established as a reachable exploit; conditional questions remain.
ECHIDNA
2026-10-08-claude-01 — COMPLETELIMITEDPROPERTY_SET. 11/11 generic ERC20 properties passed for Coin and GlazeOFT, 200k+ calls each; protocol invariants and production optimizer semantics untested.
2026-10-08-protocol-stateful-02 — BLOCKEDOPENAICYBERPOLICYPRE_EXECUTION. Isolated protocol-specific stateful extension prepared a draft harness, then received explicit OpenAI cybersecurity refusal before compilation or Echidna execution; no retry, no added coverage.
The final prepared narrow-job closeout recorded all 15 jobs terminal: five bounded proofs, six solver timeouts and four wall-stop inconclusives. Assertion replays passed 15/15; the original 16-property campaign ended with eleven bounded proofs and five unresolved properties. No confirmed counterexample was established. Bounded proofs and sampled replays do not prove omitted protocol paths. Slither had 422 raw rows (108 primary); Aderyn had 27 primary rows / 160 locations. Echidna passed 11 generic ERC20 properties for each of Coin and GlazeOFT; protocol-wide invariants were not completed.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Reviewed source: 91206a4ed18c514cdad3f8e8b09e0ca08ffd3ffb. Status captured 2026-10-07.
8 report assets are registered in the maintained report-by-report response index. Recorded categories include ASSURANCEOPEN, SOURCECLASSIFIED. Some checks were partial, refused, skipped or inconclusive; no complete campaign or live deployment is inferred. Later October 8 campaigns and October 9 Periphery regression validation are recorded separately.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Integration checks · October 6–7 follow-up
Reviewed source: 91206a4ed18c514cdad3f8e8b09e0ca08ffd3ffb. Status captured 2026-10-07.
5 report assets are registered in the maintained report-by-report response index. Recorded categories include DEFERRED. Some checks were partial, refused, skipped or inconclusive; no complete campaign or live deployment is inferred. Later October 8 campaigns and October 9 Periphery regression validation are recorded separately.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
Audit follow-ups and project responses · October 9
Reviewed source: ff973d5ca9e137f5561de88b22d8a53f221f9e19. Status captured 2026-10-09.
October 6–9 audit follow-ups
Project responses updated October 9, 2026. Original ratings and reviewer conclusions remain preserved. Acceptance is not a fix. Local validation and owner waivers do not add independent audit coverage.
October 6 reviews examined 91206a4ed18c514cdad3f8e8b09e0ca08ffd3ffb. October 8 reviews examined ff973d5ca9e137f5561de88b22d8a53f221f9e19. The October 9 Periphery fix is 517e09a33ba1c5d506566b32398f254c5121d231 and received targeted local validation, owner acceptance, and an explicit waiver of its additional independent re-audit. That review did not run.
Findings closeout
The latest registered inventory has 133 observations: 30 OpenAI and 103 Claude (including duplicates). 125 are accepted, two Periphery observations are remediated and locally validated, and six are deferred in whole or part. Zero undecided contract portions remain in that inventory. Accepted risks retain their original boundaries. Deferred work is not represented as fixed.
Blocked latest matrix cells
| Cell | Recorded outcome | Scope limitation |
|---|
| OPENKRITT-CLAUDE | DEFENSIVESUBSETNOT_FEASIBLE | Defensive subset not feasible: engine enforces malicious-actor/input/trigger-flow fields on every terminal finding. Not run; no scan created. |
| 0XSIMAO-DB | BLOCKEDOPENAISAFETYCLASSIFIERREQUIRED_LENS | Full 39-file 0xSimao method started with Daybreak/ultra. Money map and three lenses completed, but required lens-01 received an explicit OpenAI classifier refusal. Runner and in-flight calls stopped; no retry, judge or first-pass seal. |
| PASHOV-DB | BLOCKEDOPENAISAFETYCLASSIFIERPRE_DISPATCH | Full method prepared and no-source preflight passed, then OpenAI classifier stopped preparation. No source-bearing Pashov specialist or judge dispatched. |
| OPENKRITT-DB | BLOCKEDOPENAICYBERPOLICYREQUIREDNATIVESTEP | Pinned full native Daybreak/ultra external-flow-analysis scan 2 accepted and ran 38 completed step attempts. Required metadata 46 returned explicit OpenAI cyber_policy refusal; scan stopped with no retry or substitution, two in-flight jobs terminated. No post scripts, complete 39-primary model read or first-pass seal. |
The earlier 0xSimao Claude review was also blocked; removed Gemini lanes were not performed. Provider blocks, partial ToB coverage, limited generic fuzz properties, and symbolic inconclusives remain coverage limits. Mock deployment verification is separate from audit coverage and real-value release clearance.
Subsequent mock deployment
On October 9 the updated valueless mock system was redeployed on Robinhood using Candidate 02 contract bytes. All 76 deployment and positive functional transactions succeeded, followed by two configuration transactions detaching optional mock revenue after owner clarification. Two RPCs independently verified canonical receipts, 31 compiled contract runtimes and the configured contract graph. This verifies the mock release only and adds no independent audit coverage. The live GLAZE token was not redeployed or modified; the separately deployed mock revenue experiment was left unused and disconnected from active FundCoin fee routing because the owner does not need mock GLAZE.
Original executable evidence and provider transcripts remain private. This is a source-specific public summary, not a downloadable original, complete-coverage certificate or professional audit by the harness author.
